Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl tier list (March 2024) - Best and worst characters

All Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl characters

All Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl characters
March 15, 2024: October 1, 2023: We've updated our Nickelodean All-Star Brawl tier list.

You may be looking for a Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl tier list if you're looking to start up the game. As the game has been out for some time and even managed to arrive on PS Plus, plenty of players have been able to try out the game for themself.

Down below, you'll see a simple table-style tier list complete with all 20+ Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl characters currently available. The ranking takes difficulty, utility, and damage into account, meaning the top rankings go to the characters that are most likely to make a splash regardless of a player's skill.

Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl Tier List (March 2024)

Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl tier list


April O'Neil
Spongebob Squarepants
Lucy Loud


Sandy Cheeks
Nigel Thornberry
Ren and Stimpy
Hugh Neutron


Lincoln Loud
Powdered Toast Man
Invader Zim
Jenny Wakeman
Danny Phantom


Patrick Star
Helga Pataki

Keep reading for a full lowdown on why we've placed these characters in their respective tiers:

S Tier

  • Aang
  • April O'Neil
  • Leonardo
  • Lucy Loud
  • Spongebob Squarepants

All of the characters in this tier have potent kill potential. These characters are the current best picks for the game but may need to learn how to play them to be effective.

As seen on this matchup on Super Smash Con Fall Fest Grand Finals, these blistering fast characters can exert high pressure on their opponents and can kill even when their foe still has barely any damage.

Players who aim to compete must at least learn how to fight against these characters to go far.

The Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl tier list ranks each character.
expand image

A Tier

  • Catdog
  • Nigel Thornberry
  • Michelangelo
  • Sandy Cheeks
  • Ren and Stimpy
  • Oblina
  • Shredder
  • Hugh Neutron

These characters are also strong picks but pale when their tools are compared to the S tiers. However, these characters still have good kill potential.

Compared to the S tiers, these characters are strong but their flaws are much more noticeable than them. In Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl, all of these characters in this tier have effective moves that can make up a solid gameplan but have moves which are too slow or too dangerous to use outside of this plan.

Characters in the A tiers are often considered solid picks for any player who picks them up.

B Tier

  • Korra
  • Lincoln Loud
  • Reptar
  • Danny Phantom
  • Invader Zim
  • Powdered Toast Man
  • Garfield
  • Jenny Wakeman
  • Rocko

These characters are defined with a few strong gimmicks that players need to land to be successful with these characters. If these gimmicks are not landed, these characters often struggle in fights.

As seen in this B tier list, each of these characters has access to strong damage output to knock their foes in the map easily. However, their approach can be difficult as they often have inferior tools than the higher tiers or their best tools are hidden behind a gimmick or tactic that is too risky to perform.

C Tier

  • Toph
  • Patrick Star
  • Helga Pataki

Looking at these picks, these characters are the underperformers of the fighting game. Their strong moves are often overshadowed by the higher tiers as it can be easily avoided or too slow to execute on most players even at lower levels of play.

The characters in these tiers have ineffective tools mainly because their attacks and setups are too slow to use and execute. Due to their sluggish options, they often struggle against most matchups even when all their foe has is a speed advantage.


  • Michelangelo (formerly)

Prior to a previous patch, Michelangelo was considered a broken character in Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl. His infinite jumps allowed players to stall matches indefinitely while having a decent kill potential. It forced tournament organizers to ban him out of competitive play until it was patched out. As of now, no characters are banned from of the game, but Michelangelo remains a divisive choice.

For more on the game, check out how to wavedash in Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl. That's an essential skill to master at the higher levels of place, making it a must-have read for anyone looking to play at their best. Knowing how to grab and throw will help as well.

This Article's Topics

Explore new topics and discover content that's right for you!

Nickelodeon All-Star BrawlGuides