AI Reverse-Engineering of Games Is Not a Win for the Industry

AI reverse-engineering and vibe-coded decompilation are a disaster for game developers.

Elden Ring Black Ops 6 Mod mishmash
Elden Ring Black Ops 6 Mod mishmash

Generative AI has been a thorn in any creative’s side since it first bared its Will Smith eating spaghetti face to the public, and now the technology has evolved to a point where it’s ruining gaming.

You wouldn’t be able to tell, what with all the fanfare over vibecoded gaming products and newly-released emulators, but I fear that the more we let generative AI into our games, the more it's going to hurt in the long run. Now, I know this might sound cynical; I agree this is a new frontier, and I am honestly overwhelmed by just how much more ground we’re covering because of AI, but hear me out for a bit.

To understand this scary new AI era that we’re entering, we need to start from the beginning. And no, I don’t mean the type of AI that’s always been in video games, but the usage of the actual tool.

A fierce-looking character with a yellow and brown costume and distinct claws, screaming amidst a fiery backdrop.
expand image
Credit: Insomniac

From my perspective, things really started to go awry when PS5 decided to discontinue physical disc versions of their games. Sony’s decision was so dumb and outrageous that everyone in and out of the gaming community took up arms in defiance of this corporate greed. A very justified reaction to the possibility of never actually owning anything, but it also became justification for players to start using AI to decompile complicated processor architectures that separated consoles from PCs. Thus, the first stone was cast, and the AI race we see today began. 

At first, the goal was to reverse-engineer the PS5 to work on PC and create free games to be played on PC as a way to get back at corporations, but people quickly realized they could do the same for every game. For the longest time, video games have had their source code out for the world to see under the assumption that no one would be crazy enough to sift through and understand lines of spaghetti code. Fortunately (or unfortunately) for us, AI was built to do this exact thing, and suddenly every game’s source code was up for grabs, and everyone circled it like vultures waiting for a bite.

zelda ocarina playing
expand image
Credit: Nintendo

After the emulators came out, native video game ports were next. Games that were previously unavailable anywhere on the market, such as Tekken 6 and the yucky Deadpool game, were suddenly natively playable on PC for free, and most of them even had proper netcode that made them playable online. Afterwards, video game code was suddenly playable through any web browser. Then, video game modders vibecoded it to the next level and started mish-mashing video games together in some sort of Frankenstein’s monster, with my favorite by far being Leon Kennedy in Elden Ring.

Games have never been more accessible, and yet I could not be more worried about the future of gaming.

Don’t get me wrong, I believe there is a place for piracy, not that I would ever partake in this activity. This all started because a corporation let greed get the best of them, and the greatest way to hit developers is by affecting their profit margin. What people don’t see is that these corporate heads aren’t the ones getting their teeth kicked in; it’s the developers themselves who suffer. If a video game fails, the corporate side of the video game industry will always blame the developers, and they are always the first ones to go.

I will never forgive EA for canning BioWare, even when the studio’s failure was due to corporate meddling. But these are just surface-level effects, and it just gets scarier for developers the longer this goes on.

Deadpool strikes a peace sign
expand image
Credit: High Moon Studios

AI is a gluttonous machine that will keep eating data and regurgitating it to produce something with all of the flash and none of the originality. There is a reason why the most impressive things that vibecoded video games have done are either a rehash of an old game, or a Frankenstein of multiple games - it’s because none of it can create anything original.

The more source code we feed into the AI machine, the more the machine learns, and the more it can replicate video games. As we speak, original video game concepts made by human developers are being stolen by vibe-coding “developers” from right under their noses, and that’s greatly upsetting. 

So at the end of the day, people can go enjoy their browser video games and emulators, and everyone can dunk on Nintendo for getting the little green guy to work on PC. Still, I really wish this weren’t the world we were living in right now, and I have low hopes that we’ll be moving away from this any time soon. I already dread seeing AI art on Steam; what's worse is seeing vibecoded monstrosities taking the fame from other hardworking developers. 

For more like this, stick with us here at Gfinityesports.com, the best website for gaming features and opinions.