The remake of Ocarina of Time has certainly lived up to expectations, perhaps even surpassing both the original Nintendo 64 version and the 3DS remaster in terms of overall quality. Fans are certainly happy with the game, and it has become one of the best exclusives for the Nintendo Switch 2.
As someone who has been in love with the Zelda series for so long, I will admit that it is a wonderful remake, and it nearly improved everything that made the original so great. But with that said, I believe it has one gaping flaw that wasn't there before and shouldn't have been now: voice acting.
Not every character is voiced, and you can only hear spoken dialogue during cutscenes and major plot moments. I'm grateful it's limited only to that, but even so, I am part of the crowd that thinks voice acting has no place in Ocarina of Time, and that it severely diminishes the quality of the remake.
One reason is that it takes away that link between you and the story. Directors of the series, Eiji Aonuma and Miyamoto, once stated that our silent and blank-state protagonist was meant to allow us to represent ourselves in the game. Essentially, he acts as a literal link, connecting players to the fantasy world of Zelda games and fully immersing them in it.

I would like to think that the game's NPCs serve a similar purpose. In the original Ocarina of Time, every character had a unique personality, and they gave the world so much life. They made you care about what was going on, and they managed all that without speaking once. Yes, they did a few voiced-out grunts or harumps here and there, but everything they said was all through text.
In a way, it allowed for better immersion than hearing the characters speak out whatever they said. Since you don't hear them, the next best thing is to imagine how they might have sounded in your head. You give each one a voice that you think best suits them, and because you did that, you're more invested in the game's world and feel like you're actually a part of it.
It's the reason why many enjoyed and fondly remember both the Nintendo 64 and 3DS versions of Ocarina of Time, and why both are considered the best games of the series. When the remake introduced voice acting, it essentially told you how these characters are supposed to sound. Others would say it gives them more personality, but I think it takes that away from them instead.
When you could imagine how they sounded, you could make their voices as natural, flat, or even as grandiose as possible. You were part of what gave them life, making them more interesting and, as a result, made the world also interesting. Now that the remake makes them actually speak, that's no longer the case,
The voiced dialogue takes away that imaginative aspect, forcing you to listen to what the game believes they should sound like. Some might be fine with it or even like it, but there will be those who absolutely won't. At least if dialogue was only conveyed through text, you chose how it would have sounded, even if you don't really hear anything. I think that's far better, as it at least guarantees you can look forward to major character interactions and plot moments rather than dreading them due to voice acting you don't like.

Another reason why the Ocarina of Time remake shouldn't have had voice acting is that it makes major cutscenes or plot moments feel cheesy. Try to watch Link meeting Princess Zelda for the first time in the original. Despite the lack of spoken dialogue, that cutscene contained so much emotion, with the combination of music, text, and animated expressions really making it feel more emphatic than it should have.
Now, watch the remake's version. The voice acting makes Princess Zelda sound like she's conveying her emotions more exaggeratedly. It kind of takes away the impact the scene is supposed to have, even making it somewhat excruciating to witness. And it's not just that cutscene that's affected that way.
From saying goodbye to Saria to meeting Darunia, what were supposed to be special moments became cringeworthy instead, and that's all thanks to the inclusion of voice acting. There are some instances where hearing characters actually speak helps make the scene better, but those are very few compared to how the rest were butchered because of it.
The Ocarina of Time remake is still a wonderful experience, but I firmly believe it would have been better if it excluded voice acting. The other two versions of the game didn't need it and were much better without it. Hopefully, if future remakes are made, they don't include voice acting, given that the latest Ocarina of Time game sets a perfect example of its inclusion doing more harm than good.
For more like this, stick with us here at Gfinityesports.com, the best website for gaming features and opinions.

