The Game Awards 2026 nominations are here, and they’re not making the gaming community particularly happy. Granted, there’s discourse every single time Geoff Keighley announces a new batch of contenders, but this year stirred the online pot in a way we’ve never seen.
There are several decisions that have the community baffled, so I’ve taken the liberty to compile them all in one single, convenient feature for you to skim over and keep tabs on the online discourse. It goes from the biggest elephant in the room, which is nominating a game the majority of gamers haven’t even played, to controversial picks in categories they have no business being featured in.
So, what are the biggest things people are talking about The Game Award nominations?
The Biggest Game Awards 2026 Controversies
The things that fans are criticizing the most about The Game Awards nominations this time around include:
- Grand Theft Auto 6 being nominated before being released.
- Games with licensed music occupying so many spots in the Best Score and Music category.
- The lack of Fire Emblem in the Best Sim/Strategy Game category.
GTA 6 Nominations
The biggest head-scratcher for many fans was seeing Grand Theft Auto 6 become the most-nominated game at the ceremony, with eight nods. The game officially comes out on November 19, so how could it possibly be OK for Rockstar’s open-world title to show up?

Well, if we read the ground rules, it’s completely valid. Games must be out and available for the public by November 20, a date GTA 6 barely scrapes by. Not only that, the jury of voters likely had access to a review copy for weeks and is likely well-informed about GTA’s open world, mission structure, gameplay quirks, and more.
That hasn’t stopped the likes of Twitter (sorry, Elon, still not calling it X), Reddit, and other online communities from completely berating and ridiculing Geoff Keighley for making GTA the most-nominated game at the event, despite him not even having a say in which titles get nods at TGA.
In any case, if you’re curious what nominations GTA 6 landed, these are:
- Game of the Year
- Best Game Direction
- Best Narrative
- Best Art Direction
- Best Score and Music
- Best Audio Design
- Best Performance (Manni L. Perez)
- Best Action/Adventure Game
Best Score and Music Category
Music is a very important part of video games, and it’s worth celebrating… until you shine the spotlight on licensed music. That’s exactly how this category feels.

Let me break it down: both Mixtape and GTA 6 landed nods as games with the “best music” of the year. Now, while GTA 6 has French DJ Justice doing original tracks and several other artists as well, Mixtape is a compilation of mostly licensed tracks with barely anything new brought to the table.
In the same year Denshattack had composers like Tee Lopes, Shoji Meguro, Kohta Takahashi, and more join forces, or Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave delivered an outstanding orchestral score, a game like Mixtape taking up a spot is rubbing many the wrong way. To be fair, that includes me.
That’s not even taking into consideration other solid scores like Marvel Tokon’s, which perfectly encapsulates how intense a tag-fighter can feel, or Unbeatable, a rhythm game that manages to mix the intense pace of an osu!-like with actual, banging tunes rather than noise pollution destroying your eardrums.
Fire Emblem: Fortune’s Weave Snubbed
Sitting at an 89, Fortune’s Weave is one of the best-rated games of the year. Surely, it would make its way to the Best Sim/Strategy category?

Well, as it turns out, Planet Zoo 2 took its place. Don’t get me wrong, it’s likely a good game, but a game as critically acclaimed as Fortune’s Weave, part of a revered franchise within the turn-based strategy genre like Fire Emblem, being shoved to the broader Best RPG category feels wrong for fans.
Even before nominations dropped, Fire Emblem was touted as a potential overall GOTY candidate, so seeing it completely shoved to the side feels rather disappointing.
I don't think people should pay too much attention to ceremonies as it is. But I also think a more standarized guidelines should be set in place to avoid controversies and make the process much more transparent.
And that’s it. Stick with us at Gfinity: your go-to source for all things gaming

