Snubbing Pokemon Pokopia for Game of the Year Proves Cozy Games Still Get No Respect

Five million copies sold and a 98% OpenCritic score apparently still aren't enough for TGA.

A group of cartoon characters, including Pokémon, gathered in front of a building resembling a Pokémon Center.
A group of cartoon characters, including Pokémon, gathered in front of a building resembling a Pokémon Center.

Pokemon Pokopia was one of the most popular games this year, so I was expecting it to receive a couple of nominations at this year’s Game Awards.

And while I didn’t expect it to win, I even thought it had a chance of being nominated for Game of the Year. We can’t deny how successful the game was; it almost felt obvious it would be nominated. But alas, the nominees were announced, and Pokopia was nowhere on that list.

And honestly? It feels like the game was majorly snubbed.

Pokemon Pokopia Not Being Nominated for GOTY Feels Wrong

Pokemon Pokopia isn't just a spin-off from our favorite franchise. Right now, it's the highest-rated Pokemon game on Metacritic and holds a 98% recommendation score on OpenCritic. It sold over 5 million copies on the Switch 2, won the Japan Game Awards Grand Award, and was even nominated for GOTY at the Golden Joysticks.

A character with red hair is interacting with a small green creature in a grassy area, while a blue turtle-like creature is visible in the background.
expand image
Credit: Nintendo

And yet, during The Game Awards 2026, it was only nominated for Best Family Game and Best Sim/ Strategy.

It's hard not to see this as a total snub - especially since it outscores massive AAA juggernauts on Metacritic. It feels less like an oversight and more like deliberate genre gatekeeping. Was Pokemon Pokopia not nominated just because it's a cozy game?

There's an unspoken snobbery in gaming that equates quality and prestige with high-tension combat, dark themes, and bloody gore. Life sims, social sandboxes, and cozy games are rarely considered for such major awards. But just because Pokopia replaced gym battles with decor interactions, adorable dialogue, and stress-free world-building doesn't mean it's any less ambitious or mechanically deep than the games that were nominated.

I'm tired of games like Pokemon Pokopia being cast to the side just because it isn't a gritty action-adventure or soulslike game. Its cultural impact should speak for itself.

If Game of the Year is supposed to celebrate titles that sparked conversation in the gaming world, snubbing Pokopia from the nominations is laughable. It's the freshest thing the Pokemon franchise has released in decades. It revitalized the franchise's reputation, dominated social media, and gave gamers a peaceful escape from everyday life.

Cozy games aren't a lesser tier of games - they can be extremely innovative, emotionally resonant, and fun. And it’s long past time The Game Awards started treating them like real GOTY contenders.