Choosing the right gaming controller can be tricky with the sheer number of options out there, and everyone seems to have an opinion on which one you should buy. Thankfully, modern tech (and the internet’s collective wisdom) makes figuring out what’s great, what’s overrated, and what’s actually worth buying much easier. And when it comes to honest, real-world feedback, Reddit is one of the best places to look.
That said, trawling through endless threads isn’t exactly the quickest route to a decision. So, to save you the hassle, we’ve rounded up the best controllers according to Reddit for PS5, Xbox, PC, and Switch 2, based entirely on real-world experiences.
Best Controllers According to Reddit
- Reddit's Favorite PS5 Controller — Dualsense Edge
- Reddit's Favorite Xbox Controller — Razer Wolverine V3 Pro
- Reddit's Favorite PC Controller — Xbox Elite Series 2
- Reddit's Favorite Switch 2 Controller — Nintendo Switch 2 Pro
Specs:
- Compatibility — PS5, PC
- Connectivity — Wireless, Wired (USB-C)
- Battery Life — Around 6 hours
- Weight — 335 grams
Why we chose the Dualsense Edge
The DualSense Edge is a highly-rated, widely recommended controller, with threads on both r/playstation and r/consoles putting it forward as one of the best gamepads you can get for the PS5. While both acknowledge how Sony limits compatibility of third-party controllers, that doesn't take away from the fact that it's a stellar, albeit slightly premium, device that can take your skills to the next level.
It's Sony's official "Pro" gamepad, boasting adjustable triggers that can be used to reduce activation time, and mappable back paddles that can be assigned to commonly used in-game commands for quicker, easier access. It's also highly customizable, with it featuring swappable (and replaceable) stick modules, stick caps, and back paddles, and you can even save different profiles so you can switch settings in next to no time.
It's the total "Pro" package that few rival PS5 controllers can keep up with. And yes, a standard DualSense may suffice, but the DualSense Edge is a serious upgrade worth taking a look at.
Specs:
- Compatibility — Xbox, PC (Windows 11 64-bit or higher)
- Connectivity — Wireless (HyperSpeed), Wired (USB-C to USB-A)
- Battery Life — Up to 20 hours
- Weight — 304 grams
Why we chose the Razer Wolverine V3 Pro
On the r/XboxSupport subreddit, the Razer Wolverine V3 Pro is recommended as the answer to the DualSense Edge for Xbox users, particularly for shooters like Call of Duty. It's a serious bit of kit, and while you do get more of a choice when it comes to Xbox-compatible gamepads, the Wolverine V3 Pro still manages to sit near the top of the table.
Among its features, you'll find things like Razer Pro HyperTriggers that can significantly reduce the time it takes to fire your weapon, for example It also boasts Hall Effect thumbsticks that are designed to maintain their precision and accuracy, no matter how much you use the controller. Plus, it can be used wirelessly via Razer HyperSpeed technology, and it features a plethora of additional buttons, including four on the back and two claw-grip bumpers for good measure.
In short, it's got everything anyone could need for gaming, which definitely factors into its high praise over on Reddit.
Specs:
- Compatibility — PC, Xbox
- Connectivity — Wireless, Wired (USB-C)
- Battery Life — Up to 40 hours
- Weight — 345 grams
Why we chose the Xbox Elite Series 2
Now, you’d think the Xbox Elite Series 2 would dominate purely as an Xbox controller, but thanks to its unrivalled support and compatibility with Windows PCs, subreddits like r/buildapc often recommend it as one of the best options for PC gaming.
Comments such as, “I’ve been using the Xbox Elite Series 2 for about 4 years and I really like it,” put into perspective just how well-regarded this gamepad is among real-life users. And while keeping pace with skilled keyboard and mouse players is never easy, the Elite Series 2 manages to hold its own surprisingly well. Features like adjustable-tension thumbsticks, shorter hair trigger locks, and interchangeable components combine to create a controller that’s quick, precise, and seriously capable.
Perhaps the only downside is that it's getting a little old now, with many eagerly awaiting the inevitable Elite Series 3, which is presumably arriving in the not-too-distant future. Still, when it comes to PC gaming, controllers don’t get much better than the Elite Series 2 right now.
Specs:
- Compatibility — Switch 2
- Connectivity — Wireless, Wired (USB-C)
- Battery Life — Up to 40 hours
- Weight — Approx. 240 grams
Why we chose the Nintendo Switch 2 Pro
Unlike on Xbox, there aren’t a ton of controllers to choose from for the Switch 2 just yet, but even so, Nintendo’s own Switch 2 Pro Controller easily takes the crown as one of the best you can buy, earning plenty of praise from subreddits like r/NintendoSwitch2 and beyond.
Replies such as “Switch 2 Pro Controller. Love it so far” are common whenever people ask what controller they’re using, and having tried out the Switch 2 Pro controller myself, I completely understand why.
It packs customizable back buttons, upgraded HD Rumble 2 motors, an audio jack for your headset, and a dedicated “C” button to tap into the Switch 2’s GameChat features. In short, it delivers everything you’d want from a Switch 2 controller and is backed by a whole lot of positive feedback online.
Factors to Consider When Buying a Controller
- Platform compatibility – Ensure it works with your console, PC, or mobile device.
- Ergonomics & comfort – Check grip size, weight, and button layout for long sessions.
- Build quality & durability – Look for sturdy materials and responsive buttons.
- Input responsiveness – Low latency and precise controls improve gameplay accuracy.
- Connectivity – Decide between wired, wireless, or Bluetooth options.
- Battery life & charging – For wireless, consider playtime per charge and charging method.
- Customization options – Extra buttons, remappable controls, and adjustable sensitivity.
- Price vs. features – Balance budget with desired functionality and performance.
Final Thoughts
Reddit users have spoken, and their top controller picks blend comfort, precision, and lasting quality. Use these insights, as well as our expert guidance, to find the perfect match for your style and enjoy a smoother, more immersive experience.